Historical buildings incur diverse challenges associated with energy consumption, specifically those surrounding opportunities for potential improvements. Inthe U.S., space conditioning (heating, cooling and ventilation) can account for up to half of all the energy usage within a home. As a result, identificationof cost-effective methods towards enhancing energy efficiency represents critical information for homeowners and businesses alike, and a measurableestimator of potential monetary investment and return. In this paper, a two-story residential home under the protection of its city’s historical preservationcommittee is evaluated in a longitudinal study during several building renovations. This is a continuation of previous research conducted in the samelocation, which focused on differences in energy consumption using a fixed-speed and variable-speed heat pump system. Within this study, energy usage overa two-year period is considered, with specific building and equipment modifications divided into individual case studies. Energy consumption data isanalyzed against electrical and thermal measurements, meteorological conditions, and utility recordings to establish a baseline reference for comparisonacross the entire study time period. These findings illustrate both the individual and composite impacts of each renovation, and performance under avariety of dynamic environmental circumstances.