A Combined Evaluation of Three Separate Research Projects on the Effects of Thermal Environment on Learning and Performance
关于热环境对学习和表现影响的三个独立研究项目的综合评估
The importance of air-conditioning as a "comfort" factor has been generally recognized. As more and more air-conditioned classrooms are being built, the effect of thermal environment on learning has been examined in a number of studies. 1,2,3 Their findings tend to suggest that overall student performance is indeed better in air-conditioned than in non-air-conditioned classrooms. However, the evidence was inconclusive, partly because the relationship between thermal environment and learning depends upon and interacts with a number of other factors, partly because the experimental designs employed in these studies involved not only different tasks but also different students, different teachers, and different classrooms.The present paper is a report on three experiments in which the study of the relationship between thermal environment and learning involved comparison between air-conditioned and non-air-conditioned classrooms with varied learning tasks while as many other potentially influential factors as possible were held constant. Part I is a description of the three experiments, as originally run. Part II is a presentation of the results after a reorganization and re-analysis of the original data.