Two fluoride tracer tests were performed by the City of Fort Collins, Colorado during the period of
February 20, 2006 through March 17, 2006. The first test was conducted with fluoride in decreasing
mode. The second test was conducted immediately following the first test with fluoride in increasing
mode.
The purpose of this study was to provide data to:
verify and refine the hydraulic and water quality calibration of the City's existing H2OMAP
model and increase confidence in predicted velocity and flow patterns;
increase understanding of factors influencing water quality within the WDS as well as evaluate
the formation potential of, and appropriate sampling locations for, disinfection byproducts and
other water quality parameters in the WDS;
examine the influence of treated water supplied from neighboring water district inter-connections
on water quality;
comply with Initial Distribution System Evaluation (IDSE) requirements; and,
examine various scenarios related to the introduction of contaminants directly into the WDS.
Successful tracer tests require extensive planning. This includes identification of sampling site
locations, frequency of sample collection, time to start each tracer test, determination of WDS
operational conditions, communication with the public and participating facilities, identification of
staff to support sampling, assembling field equipment, documentation of sampling protocols,
coordination with the laboratory analyzing samples, etc. Anticipation of, and preparation of response
plans to, changed conditions during the tracer test is also essential. Planning for the tracer tests was
begun approximately six months prior to the first tracer test and culminated with the development of a
75-page planning document outlining procedures for tracer test execution and contingency planning.
The City's existing H2OMAP hydraulic model of its WDS was used as a tool to support preparation
of the tracer test plan. Demand data sets were developed using historic February-March demand data
for the previous seven years of record. Using the H2OMAP model, response times to
decreasing/increasing fluoride concentrations were estimated and considered in the selection of
sampling site locations, frequency of sampling, and time to begin each test. Sensitivity analyses were
performed over the range of anticipated demand conditions to validate sampling protocols.
During the tracer test, the H2OMAP model was used to predict the likely movement of the tracer
through the WDS under the hydraulic conditions observed during the initial phases of each test to
ensure that the fluoride front was captured during sampling. Following the tracer test, results were
used to verify and re-calibrate the hydraulic model such that it more closely matched observed data.
The results of tracer tests suggest excellent correlation between the H2OMAP water quality
simulation and the field sampling results leading to a high degree of confidence in the hydraulic
calibration of the City's H2OMAP model and its use for Initial Distribution System Evaluation
(IDSE) compliance. Includes figures.